8 things I wish I knew before making my first pom pom

I've been making pom poms for over 12 years now, and there are a few things I really wish someone had told me right at the start.

They’re all things I do without even thinking now, but there was definitely a time when I had to figure them out the hard way through lots of trial and error.

Tip 7 is the one people probably won’t want to hear… but it’s also one of the most important things I could tell you!

I put all 8 into a reel, but there's only so much you can squeeze into a text box, so this is the longer version with a bit more of the why.

Yarn, tinsel and scissors with yarn being wrapped onto a Clover pom pom maker

Before you even start trimming

1. Always use sharp scissors

If you try using blunt scissors you'll only hurt yourself and hate what you're doing.

A pom pom is a lot of yarn packed into a small space. Blunt scissors chew at it instead of cutting it, so you end up squeezing harder, your hand aches, and the edges come out fuzzy and ragged.

They don't need to be fancy or expensive. They just need to be sharp, and ideally kept for yarn only (hide them from anyone who wants to cut sellotape with them).

These are the ones I reach for every single day in the studio: Pom Pom Cutting Scissors

2. Tie your pom pom with more than one strand of yarn

The tie in the middle is the only thing holding the whole pom pom together, so you want to pull it really nice and tight.

The problem with a single strand is that it can snap right when you're pulling your hardest, so people tend to only knot it loosely which we don't want. Double it up (or even triple it up for extra strength) and you can pull as tight as you like without worrying about it.

If the tie is loose, bits of yarn will slide out later and eventually the pom pom will fall apart. Tight is good!

For smaller pom poms, such as when I am making earrings, I actually pull out the waxed thread for tying, which is a brilliant material to use as the wax creates grip when pulling tight.

3. Use good quality pom pom makers

You want ones that aren't going to snap after one use.

A good pom pom needs a lot of yarn wound onto the maker, and all that yarn puts pressure on it. The cheap flimsy ones just can't cope and they break, usually when you're halfway through and fully committed.

When I first started making pom poms I would buy cheap ones from ebay and couldn't understand why I kept having to replace them! At first I didn't want to spend the money on the Clover ones online, until one day I finally bit the bullet. Now 12 years later I'm still using those same Clover pom pom makers every single day!

A decent set really will last you years, so it's worth getting it right the first time. If you're only buying one set, go for the Clover M/L pom pom makers. All the other sizes are in pom pom tools.

Striped pom poms halfway through trimming, half trimmed and half untrimmed

Now for the trimming

This is where the magic happens, and it's also where most people stop too early. Tips 4 to 8 are all about the trim.

4. Use the stripes as a map

When your pom pom first comes off the maker it looks a bit of a shaggy mess, and it's hard to know where to start.

If it has stripes, use them. I follow the stripes round the pom pom to map where I trim, so I always know where I've been and where I still need to go.

If your pom pom doesn't have stripes, just imagine it does and work your way round in bands, rather than snipping at random.

For this part I use my long pom pom trimming scissors. The long blades take more off with each cut, so you get round the pom pom a lot quicker.

5. Turn your pom pom every time you trim

Snip, turn, snip, turn.

If you stay in one place you'll keep cutting the same patch and your pom pom will be wonky, usually with one flat side that you then have to trim everything else down to match.

Keeping it moving in your hand is what gets you a nice even shape.

6. Stop halfway and get a long needle out

Halfway through your trim, use a long needle to release any pieces of yarn that have got stuck or pushed out of place.

You'll be surprised how many longer bits pop out once you do this. They were hiding in there the whole time!

Then when you go back to trimming, your pom pom will come out so much smoother.

This is the one I use: 6 inch metal needle

7. You may think you're done trimming. You aren't done

Keep trimming.

The more you trim, the denser your pom pom becomes and the better the shape gets. That neat, tightly packed look only shows up once you've taken off a lot more than feels sensible.

Yes, it will end up smaller than when you started. That's completely fine, and a small dense pom pom looks so much better than a big floppy one.

8. Switch to embroidery scissors for the end

Bigger scissors are great for taking off the bulk, but near the end you want something smaller.

Sharp embroidery scissors let you get in close and do the most detailed trimming, tidying up the little stray bits and getting the surface really smooth.

Something small like these 9cm Milward scissors are perfect for it.

Bird's eye view of trimmed striped pom poms in various sizes

That's all 8!

If you only remember two of them, make it sharp scissors and keep trimming!

If you'd like to have a go, the Make Your First Pom Pom Kit is a good place to start, and all my scissors, makers and needles are in pom pom tools.

And if you make one, please tag me so I can see it. I love seeing your pom poms!

Jess x

Leave a comment